Martin & Sons LLC

Repair vs. Replace: How Do I Know Which Route To Take for My Roof?


Your home’s roof plays a critical role in keeping your home safe, dry, and protected. When there are issues with your roof, it can quickly result in problems in other areas. Roof issues can lead to leaking, mold growth, and an array of other costly and potentially dangerous problems. For this reason, it is imperative to address any problems that arise in a timely manner.

When dealing with roof issues, you have the ability to perform repairs or a complete replacement. Each option has pros and cons; however, it is important to understand when each option may be best for you. 

Determining When Roof Repair is Appropriate

Your roof’s integrity relies on multiple layers, with shingles acting as the primary defense against the elements. Regular inspections are crucial to detect any missing or damaged shingles, which can typically be repaired, especially for newer roofs. However, if uncertainties arise about underlying issues, consulting our professionals at Martin & Sons LLC for a thorough assessment is advisable. 

Undetected damages may warrant a roof replacement, highlighting the importance of regular inspections to address faults immediately and prevent further complications.

Identifying When Roof Replacement is Necessary

While roof repair can manage deterioration to a certain extent, there comes a point when replacement becomes inevitable for your home’s roofing system. Although a larger undertaking than repairs, a roof replacement ensures reliable protection and peace of mind against future issues. Signs such as moisture infiltration or multiple leaks indicate the urgency of replacement to prevent structural damage and mold growth. 

Additionally, severe weather conditions and aging roofs amplify the need for replacement to maintain the integrity of your home. As roofs near the end of their lifespan, typically after 20 to 30 years, scheduling a replacement as soon as possible becomes imperative, protecting your property from further deterioration.

The Benefits of Getting a Roof Repair

Choosing to have roof repairs performed instead of replacing the entire roof can provide several benefits. These include:


Roof repairs are generally more affordable than full replacements. By addressing specific issues such as damaged shingles, leaks, or minor structural problems, you can extend the lifespan of your roof without the significant expense of a complete replacement.


Roof repairs typically require less time to complete compared to a full replacement. This means less disruption to your daily routine and quicker resolution of any issues affecting your roof’s integrity.

Preservation of Roof Lifespan

Prompt repairs can prevent minor issues from escalating into more significant problems that may require a roof replacement. By addressing damage early, you can extend the overall lifespan of your roof and postpone the need for a costly replacement.

Environmental Impact

Opting for repairs instead of replacement can be more environmentally friendly. Repairing specific areas of damage reduces the amount of material waste generated compared to tearing off and disposing of an entire roof. This approach aligns with sustainable practices and reduces the environmental footprint of your roofing project.

The Benefits of Getting a Roof Replacement

Several benefits come with getting a roof replacement instead of performing repairs to your roof. These include:

Enhanced Longevity

A new roof provides a fresh start with materials that are free from wear and tear. This means your roof will have an extended lifespan, offering protection for many years to come without the need for frequent repairs.

Improved Energy Efficiency

Modern roofing materials and techniques used in replacements often offer better insulation and ventilation, resulting in improved energy efficiency for your home. This can lead to reduced heating and cooling costs over time.

Increased Property Value

A new roof can improve the curb appeal of your home. As a result, it can result in an increase in the overall value of your property. Buyers who may be interested in purchasing your home tend to be more attracted to places that have recently replaced roofs. This is due to the fact that a new roof often signifies structural integrity and minimal maintenance requirements.

Comprehensive Warranty Coverage

Roof replacements typically come with warranties that cover materials and workmanship for an extended period. This offers peace of mind, knowing that you are protected against defects or issues that may arise after installation, reducing the financial burden of future repairs.

Deciding Between Roof Repair and Replacement

Now that you know the benefits of repairing and replacing a roof, it is important to consider factors when determining which option will work best for you.

Roof Age

Assessing the age of your roof is critical. Typically, asphalt shingle roofs last 20 to 25 years with proper maintenance. Seek guidance from our team of skilled contractors if you are unsure.

Roof Condition

Evaluate the extent of the damage. Minor to moderate issues may warrant repairs, but severe damage may necessitate replacement. A thorough inspection is essential to uncover hidden problems.

Future Plans

Consider your long-term residency. If you are planning to sell soon, repairs may suffice. However, an aged roof affects curb appeal and may impact the selling price.

Insurance Coverage

Determine if your homeowner’s insurance covers the costs related to repairs or replacement. Valid claims depend on the cause of damage, which our team at Martin & Sons LLC can help you navigate. Assessing insurance options is crucial in making an informed decision.

It is in your best interest to seek help from our dedicated professionals. Our team will be able to evaluate your roof and determine the best options available. We will determine whether or not it makes more sense to repair damage to your roof or to consider an entire roof replacement. Our team will also provide you with an estimate for both routes so you know what to expect moving forward.

Contact Our Team Now

At Martin & Sons LLC, we pride ourselves on providing professional residential roofing services in St. Louis. Our team of experienced and knowledgeable owners will work with you from start to finish to find the best roofing solution for your home and budget. 

Say goodbye to feeling pressured into investing in expensive products. We focus on helping you make an informed decision that meets your needs. Do not waste any more time searching for “roofing contractors near me,” contact Martin & Sons LLC today for top-quality roofing services you can trust. Reach out to our team in Florissant, MO, by calling (314) 839-0700 to schedule an estimate


Call Us Today For A Free Estimate On Your Remodeling Project!

Scroll to Top